In a surprising pivot during the American League Wild Card Series, New York Yankees manager Aaron Boone opted to start rookie Ben Rice at first base over veteran Paul Goldschmidt for Game 3 against the Boston Red Sox on Wednesday night. This came just a day after Boone had publicly declared that Goldschmidt would face every left-handed pitcher in the postseason. The decision, against a lefty starter for Boston, underscores the ongoing tug-of-war at the position that's defined much of the Yankees' 2025 campaign.
Rice, the 26-year-old breakout sensation from Cohasset, Massachusetts, has been nothing short of electric since earning a regular spot early in the season. His 171 OPS+ over 50 games last year ballooned into a full-season story of power and poise, with 28 homers and a .892 OPS that propelled New York deep into October. Indeed, Rice's hot streak through the regular season's final weeks forced the issue, turning what was meant to be a platoon arrangement into a genuine competition. Boone cited Rice's recent form against lefties—hitting .320 with three homers in September—as the tipping point, even as Goldschmidt remained a steady presence.
Goldschmidt, the 37-year-old former NL MVP signed to a one-year deal in the offseason, brought pedigree and experience to the Bronx. He revived his career midseason, slashing .285/.370/.510 over the final two months, including a ridiculous road trip that saw him homer in four straight games. Yet, for all his postseason pedigree with 12 homers in October play, the veteran's splits against left-handers (.240 average this year) have been a lingering concern. Moreover, whispers of the Yankees eyeing Rice as their long-term first baseman have grown louder, especially with Goldschmidt's contract expiring and reports suggesting a potential parting of ways.
The lineup shuffle didn't pay immediate dividends—Rice went 0-for-3 in a 4-2 loss that pushed the series to a decisive Game 4—but it highlighted Boone's willingness to lean on youth amid pressure. However, with the Yankees' season on the line, the choice raises questions about balancing proven grit against raw potential. As the playoffs grind on, one can't help but wonder if this bold stroke will define Rice's ascent or expose the risks of sidelining a seven-time All-Star.