Andy Richter, the longtime late-night comedian known for his quick wit alongside Conan O'Brien, has unexpectedly become a standout on Season 34 of Dancing with the Stars. Paired with pro dancer Emma Slater, Richter debuted on September 16 with a foxtrot that, while not flawless, captured audiences through sheer personality. Indeed, his self-deprecating humor has turned what could have been a forgettable stint into a fan favorite arc.
The show, which kicked off with high energy and no immediate cuts, delivered its first double elimination just a week later on September 23. Richter dodged the axe, alongside stars like Robert Irwin and Danielle Fishel, while Corey Feldman and Baron Davis packed their bags after low scores on "One-Hit Wonders Night." Feldman, scoring a mere 24 out of 50 on his cha-cha to Sir Mix-a-Lot's "Baby Got Back," seemed outmatched from the start. Richter, by contrast, has leaned into his underdog status, admitting on O'Brien's podcast that he's in it partly for the paycheck—a blunt confession that endeared him further to viewers.
Moreover, Richter nearly backed out before rehearsals even began, citing fears of the grueling routine. However, once committed, he and Slater have churned out rehearsal videos that are lighting up social media. Their TikToks, blending clumsy steps with infectious laughter, have racked up views and even virtual 10s on the 'For You' page. This past Tuesday's TikTok Night saw them perform another foxtrot, infused with emotional depth that highlighted Richter's personal growth, including his stable marriage to Jennifer Herrera Richter.
Yet, not everything's smooth. Richter confessed to breaching show protocol by spilling details early, risking a firing that thankfully never came. His take on the competition? It's more entertainment than pure dance-off, where votes can keep charmers like him afloat longer than skill alone might allow. As eliminations ramp up, Richter's blend of comedy and effort keeps him relevant.
With 12 contestants left and the leaderboard tightening, one wonders if Richter's relatable vibe can carry him deeper into the season.