Colts may reconsider trade of Jonathan Taylor after Giants offer rejected

The Indianapolis Colts are reportedly reconsidering their stance on trading running back Jonathan Taylor following the rejection of a previous offer from the New York Giants. According to NFL insider Jordan Schultz, the Giants had offered second- and fifth-round picks for Taylor, a package the Colts initially declined. Schultz stated that Indianapolis would “strongly consider” a similar package if it were put back on the table.

This potential shift in strategy comes as the 2026 NFL trade deadline approaches, scheduled for 4 p.m. ET on Tuesday, November 10. The Colts lost their fifth consecutive game on Sunday, falling to the Dallas Cowboys at home. In the aftermath of that loss, Taylor expressed uncertainty regarding his future with the franchise. Schultz noted that Taylor is “open to be traded” and might “welcome a fresh start at this point,” although the running back has not submitted a formal trade request.

Taylor, a three-time Pro Bowler, recently signed a two-year, $44 million contract extension that runs through the 2028 season. While the Colts appear content to keep him in the fold unless he actively pushes for an exit, Schultz suggested that the team could revisit a trade in the offseason. However, with more options available to other teams, the Giants’ current offer may represent the best package the Colts can secure now or in the future. Multiple reports indicate that the Giants could re-engage in trade talks as the deadline nears.